Panini Pie Factory

Menu & services

The full spread

Artisan pies & pressed paninis in farmingdale — everything we serve, from morning to night.

Signature Fruit Pies at Panini Pie Factory

Service 1

Signature Fruit Pies

Apple, cherry, blueberry, and seasonal specials — hand-crimped crusts and fillings made from real fruit, never canned goo.

Service 2

Savory Pot Pies

Chicken, beef, and veggie pot pies with golden, buttery tops. Dinner in a crust.

Savory Pot Pies at Panini Pie Factory
Pressed Paninis at Panini Pie Factory

Service 3

Pressed Paninis

Fresh-baked bread pressed hot with prosciutto, mozzarella, roasted peppers, and house spreads.

Service 4

Custom Celebration Pies

Weddings, holidays, office parties — order ahead and we'll bake to your headcount.

Custom Celebration Pies at Panini Pie Factory
Morning Pastries at Panini Pie Factory

Service 5

Morning Pastries

Croissants, danishes, and coffee-cake slices for the morning rush, baked fresh daily.

Service 6

Catering Platters

Pie flights and panini platters for events across Farmingdale and Nassau County.

Catering Platters at Panini Pie Factory

How it works

Dinner here is effortless

Four easy steps between you and a great meal at Panini Pie Factory.

Call or stop by

Check the day's case or order ahead for parties and holidays.

Pick your pie

Forty-plus varieties rotate through — fruit, savory, and seasonal.

We bake it fresh

Small batches, real butter crusts, honest fillings.

Take it home warm

Best served slightly warm with a scoop of vanilla. You're welcome.

Hungry? Come see us.

Panini Pie Factory is serving Farmingdale right now — call ahead for takeout or just follow your nose to 71 Milbar Blvd, Farmingdale, NY 11735.

☎ Call Panini Pie Factory · 347-541-9874