Artisan pies & pressed paninis in Farmingdale

Pies Baked Like Somebody Cares

Small-batch artisan pies and hot pressed paninis from our Farmingdale kitchen — flaky crust, real fruit, zero shortcuts.

Small-Batch BakingCustom OrdersFresh Daily
★★★★★
Artisan pies & pressed paninis in FarmingdaleLoved by locals
Tue–Sun 8:00 AM – 6:00 PMWalk-ins welcome

What we do

Made fresh, served warm

Everything Panini Pie Factory is known for, under one roof in Farmingdale.

Signature Fruit Pies at Panini Pie Factory

Signature Fruit Pies

Apple, cherry, blueberry, and seasonal specials — hand-crimped crusts and fillings made from real fruit, never canned goo.

Explore services →
Savory Pot Pies at Panini Pie Factory

Savory Pot Pies

Chicken, beef, and veggie pot pies with golden, buttery tops. Dinner in a crust.

Explore services →
Pressed Paninis at Panini Pie Factory

Pressed Paninis

Fresh-baked bread pressed hot with prosciutto, mozzarella, roasted peppers, and house spreads.

Explore services →
Custom Celebration Pies at Panini Pie Factory

Custom Celebration Pies

Weddings, holidays, office parties — order ahead and we'll bake to your headcount.

Explore services →
Morning Pastries at Panini Pie Factory

Morning Pastries

Croissants, danishes, and coffee-cake slices for the morning rush, baked fresh daily.

Explore services →
Catering Platters at Panini Pie Factory

Catering Platters

Pie flights and panini platters for events across Farmingdale and Nassau County.

Explore services →

By the numbers

A Farmingdale favorite, by every measure

0Pie varieties baked*
0Real butter crusts*
0Days a week fresh*
0Pies out the door*

* Illustrative figures shown for this demo website.

Before & after

Same room. Whole different feeling.

A great room does half the work of a great meal. Drag the slider to compare a tired space with the warm, cared-for room Panini Pie Factory keeps for its guests.

Tired, dated dining room before Panini Pie Factory
Warm, inviting dining room at Panini Pie Factory
↔
BeforeAfter

How it works

Dinner here is effortless

Four easy steps between you and a great meal at Panini Pie Factory.

Call or stop by

Check the day's case or order ahead for parties and holidays.

Pick your pie

Forty-plus varieties rotate through — fruit, savory, and seasonal.

We bake it fresh

Small batches, real butter crusts, honest fillings.

Take it home warm

Best served slightly warm with a scoop of vanilla. You're welcome.

Word on the street

What Farmingdale keeps saying

★★★★★
“The apple pie tastes like my grandmother's — flaky crust, not too sweet. I order one for every holiday now.”
— Holiday regular, Farmingdale
★★★★★
“Stopped for a panini, left with two pies. The chicken pot pie reheated perfectly for dinner.”
— Lunch convert, Bethpage
★★★★★
“Ordered a pie platter for our office party and it was gone in twenty minutes. Booking again for Thanksgiving.”
— Office manager, Melville

Good to know

Questions, answered

Day-of pies are first-come, first-served. For holidays or parties of any size, call 347-541-9874 a few days ahead.
We rotate gluten-free crusts and reduced-sugar fillings — call ahead and we'll tell you what's in the case.
Yes — custom orders for weddings, corporate events, and holidays are our specialty. Let's talk headcount and flavors.
Tuesday through Sunday, 8:00 AM to 6:00 PM. Closed Mondays so the ovens can rest.
Local pickup and nearby delivery are our bread and butter. Call about delivery to your town.
71 Milbar Boulevard in Farmingdale — follow the smell of butter and cinnamon.

Proudly serving

Around Farmingdale & beyond

Guests join us from all over the area — come see why Panini Pie Factory is worth the trip.

Get in touch

Planning a visit or an event? Let's talk.

Tell us what you need and we'll get back to you shortly — or just call 347-541-9874.

Please enter your name (at least 2 characters).

Please enter a valid phone number (at least 7 digits).

Prefer to call? 347-541-9874

✓

Thanks — we got it!

Someone from Panini Pie Factory will reach out shortly. Hungry now? Call 347-541-9874.

Hungry? Come see us.

Panini Pie Factory is serving Farmingdale right now — call ahead for takeout or just follow your nose to 71 Milbar Blvd, Farmingdale, NY 11735.

☎ Call Panini Pie Factory · 347-541-9874